Best Pizza in Monticello, NY

December 31st, 2018 by

aerial view of two veggie pizzas on a wooden surface

The title for best Monticello pizza is hotly contested —Monticello residents and visitors from Monroe and Warwick all have their go-to pizza places. If you are looking for a change from your everyday chain like Pizza Hut and want to find out what real local pizza tastes like, explore some of our favorite pizza restaurants in Monticello, NY.

Contact Us

Colosseo Family Restaurant & Pizzeria

Colosseo is a favorite of locals and visitors alike, having won nods from Trip Advisor in 2015 as one of the top 3 best pizza places and top 5 best Italian cuisine restaurants in the area. Come for lunch or dinner and build your own pizza with classic and specialty toppings.

Pizza the Rock

Pizza the Rock is a regular haunt for people in the area and a great place to take the family, with fun decor, hefty toppings, and a large menu so discerning palates and picky eaters can find something they like. Be sure to get the garlic knots!

Papa Luke’s Pizzeria

Papa Luke’s is another Monticello favorite, with casual vibes, friendly service, and fresh ingredients. Many say it’s as good as any slice you can get in New York City, and you can even menu items like Chicago deep dish penne chicken vodka pizza.

Siena’s Pizza

Siena’s Pizza has everything you could want from a casual Italian restaurant, from sandwiches to seafood to pasta dishes, and of course pizza with homemade sauce. They offer a long list of both Sicilian and Neapolitan-style pizzas, and specialty stuffed pizza options.

Fialkoff’s Kosher Pizza

If you are looking for kosher restaurants outside of New York City, you may be surprised to find one serving amazing pizza in Monticello. Those that know about Fialkoff’s can’t get enough of it, so make the trip and try out this small family pizza place!

Couple eating pizza outdoors and smiling.They are sharing pizza in a outdoor cafe.
Home made italian pizza with salami and cheese

Explore the Area with Middletown Honda

If you want to go on another culinary adventure, check out the best restaurants in Goshen, NY!  Let us know if you want any more local recommendations, and visit Middletown Honda for all your automotive needs in the Goshen and Monticello area!

Learn More at Middletown Honda

  • Does the Honda CR-V Have AWD?

    Yes! The 2019 Honda CR-V does offer AWD as an option for Monroe drivers. At each CR-V trim level, you have the choice to upgrade to the Real Time AWD with Intelligent Control System™. Explore the Honda CR-V AWD system at Middletown Honda, then contact us to take a test drive and experience it in person….

  • How Spacious is Honda Pilot Cargo Space?

    The 2019 Honda Pilot offers a spacious interior a lot of cargo space. The Pilot’s three-row SUV offers 16.5 cubic feet of cargo volume when the rear seats are in us. When you fold the third row down to expand the cargo area, you will get 46.8 cubic feet. Get more space by folding down…

  • Best Pizza in Monticello, NY

    The title for best Monticello pizza is hotly contested —Monticello residents and visitors from Monroe and Warwick all have their go-to pizza places. If you are looking for a change from your everyday chain like Pizza Hut and want to find out what real local pizza tastes like, explore some of our favorite pizza restaurants in…

Posted in Local Information